Propel Marketing
Case study

How Propel Went From Zero AI Presence to the #1 AI Search Rank Against 840+ Competitors

No Google presence and no AI citations in a market owned by Klaviyo and Braze. Propel now ranks #1 on AI search for the questions its buyers ask.

Client
Propel Marketing
Industry
SaaS B2B ยท Lifecycle & Retention Marketing
Services
SEO + AEO (AI search) Strategy & Execution
Website
https://www.trypropel.ai
#1 of 450
AI search rank
#2 of 805
AI citation rank
19
AI visibility score
15+
New clients per month via search and AI
150+
Pages built and interlinked for AI search
5
AI tools tested, #1 rank across all

The challenge

Propel entered a crowded market. More than 840 competitors, led by Klaviyo, Customer.io, Braze and Mixpanel, had years of search authority behind them. Propel had no presence on Google and no citations in ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini or Copilot.

Catching up on Google in a few months wasn't realistic. But AI tools had become a real way for B2B buyers to shortlist lifecycle marketing vendors, and Propel wasn't there either.

So the question was where to compete: fight for scraps on Google, or show up first in a channel where nobody had locked in an advantage yet.

The strategy

AI search was still wide open, even in a category where Google was locked up.

So we built Propel's authority in AI answers first and let that visibility feed back into Google. We didn't compete head-on for rankings Propel couldn't win in the short term.

What we built

The work came in four parts.

1. Research based on how buyers ask AI tools

We mapped the questions buyers actually type into ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini, not just Google search volume. That turned up high-intent, comparison-style questions where almost no one was competing for the AI answer, even in spaces where Google was already crowded.

2. 150+ interlinked pages built to be quoted

Every page opens with a short, self-contained answer before going deeper. That's the format ChatGPT, Gemini and AI Overviews pull from most. Pages link to each other by topic, and were built to win Google's featured snippets and AI citations at the same time.

3. Structured data that makes Propel easy to understand

We added structured data across the site: labels for the company, products, reviews, FAQs and competitor comparisons. It gives Google and AI tools clear signals about what Propel does and how it stacks up, which helps with both rich results and citations.

4. Testing across five AI tools

We ran continuous checks on ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot and Grok. Ask the question, see who gets cited, work out why, revise. That loop took Propel to #1 on every tool we tested.

The results

Propel now ranks #1 on AI search for the questions buyers ask when shortlisting lifecycle and retention marketing agencies, across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Copilot and Grok.

Propel ranks #1 of 450 on AI search, ahead of Klaviyo, Customer.io and Braze
Propel ranks #1 of 450 on AI search, ahead of Klaviyo, Customer.io and Braze.

How it grew

In the first two months of tracking (May and June 2025), weekly Google impressions rose from 8,120 to 18,000, a 2.2X lift. The number of keywords Propel ranked for grew from 12 to 124, and its SEMrush Authority Score went from 12 to 18. By December, it ranked for 362 keywords.

Charts of Propel weekly Google impressions from May to June 2025 and ranking keywords growing from 12 to 124 to 362
Weekly Google impressions (May to Jun 2025) and number of ranking keywords (start, Jun 2025, Dec 2025).
Google Search Console performance for Propel, 28 days to 30 May 2025, all countries and United States
Google Search Console, 28 days to 30 May 2025: all countries and United States.

Live performance data (SEMrush, Dec 2025)

SEMrush Domain Overview for trypropel.ai on 3 December 2025
SEMrush Domain Overview for trypropel.ai, 3 Dec 2025.
19
AI visibility score
38
AI mentions
116
Pages cited by AI
21
Authority Score
362
Organic keywords (+18%)
273
Organic traffic (+19%)
271
Referring domains
2.5K
Backlinks

The takeaway

We treated AI search as an open opportunity, not a smaller version of Google. That took Propel from invisible to the top AI search rank in a market of 840+ established competitors, without having to out-age their search authority.